The proof of the pudding is in the eating, they say.
This is a podcast by Hiran de Silva. Narrated by Bill.
In today’s landscape, we’re inundated with white papers, marketing materials, and industry commentary, all pushing the business world toward high-cost IT solutions by way of compelling, often rhetorical, claims. Unfortunately, this rhetoric often leverages a lack of familiarity with Excel’s true capabilities in enterprise contexts. In this benchmarking initiative, we aim to clarify and challenge these narratives with evidence-driven assessments, showcasing the power of professional Excel solutions alongside alternative tools. This is more than an exercise in software evaluation; it’s an opportunity to address gaps in understanding Excel’s potential as an enterprise solution.
We will establish a series of high-level enterprise requirements and invite various alternative solutions, ERP systems, and IT-led systems to address these benchmarks. We will also include professional-grade Excel implementations, inviting a broad range of options to compete on the same playing field. The benchmarks will be structured to evaluate not only the quality of the results but also the cost, implementation time, potential disruptions, and flexibility to scale with evolving business needs.
Examining ERP Systems and IT-Managed Solutions.
Enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems and similar solutions managed by IT departments are central to our analysis. While these are promoted as end-to-end solutions, they come with considerable cost, lengthy deployment times, and a fixed structure that may not align with dynamic business demands. We will assess these systems on multiple fronts:
– Effectiveness of Results: How accurately and efficiently does the system meet the enterprise’s requirements?
– Cost and Time to Implement: What are the financial and time costs of rolling out these solutions?
– Flexibility and Scalability: Can these systems adapt to changing business needs, or do they risk becoming obsolete?
– Disruption and Maintenance: What level of operational disruption accompanies implementation and maintenance?
This analysis aims to reveal not only how ERP systems measure up in specific business scenarios but also the broader implications of investing in these solutions long-term.
The Alternatives to Excel – And Why They May Not Measure Up.
Alongside ERP systems, we will explore the multitude of alternatives that claim to outshine Excel. In recent years, countless solutions have emerged, each touting unique advantages, but often overlooking the value Excel brings in terms of accessibility, customizability, and cost-efficiency. These tools frequently find their way into organizations based on recommendations shaped by influencer content and marketing campaigns rather than grounded, empirical evidence.
Our benchmarking project will critically assess how these tools perform against Excel in professional settings, especially in scenarios where flexibility and agility are paramount. By comparing each solution’s real-world efficacy, scalability, and adaptability, we aim to cut through the promotional noise and bring clarity to decision-makers who may feel overwhelmed by options.
Professional Excel vs. Influencer-Driven Techniques.
A crucial aspect of this initiative is examining Excel content promoted on social media. Much of this content is designed for quick engagement, with flashy techniques and trendy “hacks” that may capture attention but lack depth and relevance for enterprise-level challenges. We will contrast these popular Excel techniques with professional, scalable solutions that prioritize sustainable value over social media appeal. Our goal is to highlight the distinction between methods that are effective for social media demonstration and those that are impactful for enterprise use.
Bringing Clarity to Excel’s Role in the Enterprise.
Through this benchmarking, we aim to provide a transparent, science-backed view of Excel’s capacity as a robust enterprise tool. To our knowledge, no similar initiative currently exists to independently evaluate claims made by various technology vendors and influencers. By conducting these assessments in a controlled, comparative setting, we hope to deliver clarity that has long been missing in the conversation around Excel.
This initiative is not only for seasoned professionals but also for newcomers and learners in the Excel ecosystem. By understanding what Excel can achieve in a professional setting, aspiring Excel users can make informed decisions about which skills will best align with their career goals. Instead of following trends, learners will have a roadmap for developing relevant, practical Excel skills based on real business impact.
Our benchmarking initiative is poised to offer answers that are grounded in empirical study, allowing businesses and learners alike to navigate the landscape of data management solutions with confidence. We look forward to opening a meaningful dialogue around Excel’s place in the enterprise and inviting all parties–from software vendors to Excel advocates–to demonstrate their capabilities in a transparent, real-world setting.
Thank you.
This is a podcast by Hiran de Silva. Narrated by Bill.
Add comment